The Abdirahman Abdi inquest is being livestreamed during the day here.
More than eight years after 38-year-old Somali-Canadian Abdirahman Abdi died following a violent altercation with Ottawa police, a four-week coroner’s inquest is diving back into the circumstances of his high-profile death.
The constable who punched Abdi in the head while trying to handcuff him was acquitted of manslaughter in 2020, and the family settled a lawsuit with police later that year.
So what’s left to unpack?
Lots, according to the inquest’s statement of scope, especially when it comes to the police service’s policies and training on everything from use of force to anti-Black racism.
Abdi’s death was ‘tragic and unnecessary,’ according to a statement released by his family on the first day of the inquest. (Abdi family)
The fact-finding mission is also looking at what happened before the encounter including Abdi’s background and his struggle with mental illness, as well as the event’s aftermath.
The fully virtual inquest began Nov. 18 and is expected to last 21 days or more. At its conclusion, five jurors pulled from the Ottawa region will likely present a list of non-binding recommendations for how to prevent deaths like Abdi’s in the future.
Inquests are not criminal proceedings but are more free-ranging in their lines of inquiry than trials.
Here’s a guide to what’s been learned so far — and what we can expect next.
Day 1: A rare glimpse into Abdi’s past
Lawyer Lawrence Greenspon stands with some of Abdi’s relatives during a rally in 2020. (Justin Tang/The Canadian Press)
Through a lawyer, Abdi’s loved ones delivered an opening statement cataloguing the emotional toll suffered by his family — including a daughter born seven months after his death.
The inquest then heard from its first witness, a psychiatrist who was visiting Ottawa and who happened to be one of the civilians to come in contact with Abdi before police stepped in.
Day 2: What led police to Abdi
Abdi groped women in and near this Hintonburg coffee shop before police stepped in. (Guy Quenneville/CBC)
Officers were responding to calls that Abdi had groped women in his Hintonburg neighbourhood.
An off-duty paramedic gave his account of the chaotic moments before police arrived.
Day 3: Former constable testifies
Const. Dave Weir, left, and Const. Daniel Montsion, right, are seen kneeling beside Abdi outside his apartment building on Hilda Street. (Still from YouTube video)
David Weir, the first officer to try to arrest Abdi, told the inquest that July 2016 day is the reason he’s no longer working as a police officer.
“This call has been traumatic for me, and still is to this day,” Weir said.
Day 4: Weir and Abdi family lawyer spar
Weir and Abdi face each other before Abdi is taken down and handcuffed. (CBC)
Weir accused Lawrence Greenspon, an Abdi family lawyer, of trivializing parts of his testimony, while Greenspon dug in on the issue of de-escalation.
Under later questioning by an advocacy group for people in police-involved incidents, Weir said he was not aware anti-Black racism is a systemic issue in policing.
Day 5: Montsion breaks his silence
Montsion arrives at the courthouse on the second day of his 2019-2020 trial for manslaughter in Abdi’s death. A judge found him not guilty. (Robyn Miller/CBC)
Const. Daniel Montsion didn’t testify at his own criminal trial, but did offer his first public account of the Abdi arrest to close out the inquest’s first week.
“It was on my mind that this might be a mental health call,” Montsion said, later adding that with Abdi being assaultive, “it was past that point.”
Day 6: Tension and confusion at the hospital
Abdi family friend Nimao Ali announced Abdi’s death on July 25, 2016, outside the Civic campus of The Ottawa Hospital. (CBC)
The second week kicked off with a family friend who documented the altercation’s aftermath on video and fought for the family’s need to say a final prayer for Abdi as he lay in hospital.
The ER doctor in charge of Abdi’s care then talked about a lack of information from police around the circumstances of what brought Abdi to the hospital.
Day 7: A view from within
Weir, Montsion and Abdi grappled outside the front entrance of this apartment building. Abdi’s name is still scrawled on the wall. A plaque in his memory was installed a year after his death. (Guy Quenneville/CBC)
The lone witness was Carla Shipley with Unity Housing, the group that operates the apartment building where Abdi and his family lived. Weir and Montsion grappled with Abdi outside its front entrance.
Most residents are from marginalized and racialized communities, and tenants have resisted increased police presence and the idea of having an Ottawa police representative sit on Unity’s board, Shipley said.
Shipley has also heard from some Ottawa police officers since Abdi’s death that they’re concerned about going to the building because they fear the residents will not work with them.
“It’s definitely a very strained relationship,” she said.
Who’s left to testify
Originally, 27 witnesses were expected to testify, though as often happens during inquests, the list is fluid. At least one witness — one of the civilians who saw part of the altercation — has already been dropped.
Here are the remaining witnesses still expected to testify:
-
One of the paramedics who treated Abdi.
-
The psychiatrists who cared for Abdi in the months before his confrontation with police. One of them found Abdi “evidenced a schizophrenia spectrum illness,” the inquest has heard. A separate expert in psychiatry is also expected.
-
Several members of the Ottawa Police Service including Deputy Chief Steve Bell; a sergeant with the force’s mental health unit; a superintendent who will discuss training on “intercultural competence”; and an officer involved in the identification and management of 911 calls where mental health issues are suspected.
These gloves with reinforced knuckles, entered as evidence in Montsion’s trial, will continue to be a talking point during the inquest. (Office of the Chief Coroner)
-
An Ontario Police College instructor.
-
Representatives from the Ottawa Guiding Council for Mental Health and Addictions.
-
A member of the Empowerment Council, a group that represents people struggling with their mental health.
-
An expert on use-of-force data.
-
Marty Carr, current vice-chair of the Ottawa Police Services Board, the police force’s oversight body.
Key texts
A number of exhibits are being submitted and helping inform the inquest testimony. Here’s a link to some of the major ones, along with a decision that hovers over the proceedings: the judge’s written decision of non-guilt in Montsion’s manslaughter case.
WATCH / A video refresher on the Abdi story — and some key questions going into the inquest: