For about 48 hours last week, it looked like a debt ceiling fight in 2025 would be averted as ideas were floated to push the issue off until 2027 or 2029 (or even forever).
But it was not to be.
Democrats and about three dozen of the most conservative Republicans made common cause to reject a plan that included a debt ceiling extension. That led to passage late Friday of a bill that averted a shutdown while leaving the debt ceiling issue untouched.
Now, with default still on the table for 2025, the next step in that process now comes on Jan. 1 when — as per a 2023 agreement between President Joe Biden and then-House Speaker Kevin McCarthy — a temporary suspension of the debt limit ends and a cap on the US government borrowing authority will be back in place.
The debt limit will then have been reached, but the Treasury Department has the means to delay a default for a few months using a process called “extraordinary measures.“
Basically, they can move money around various government accounts to delay an actual default on U.S. obligations. But it only works for a short period.
“The period of time that extraordinary measures may last is subject to considerable uncertainty due to a variety of factors,” Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen wrote in 2023 during the last standoff.
The U.S. Capitol is seen through a steam vent on March 06, 2024 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images) ·Kevin Dietsch via Getty Images
All things considered, questions about government default could again weigh on the economy in the early months of 2025. Here’s some of the early thinking about how the next round could play out.
What happens after Jan. 1 will be what is essentially an educated guessing game about when the moment comes that these extraordinary measures run out and an actual default could be in the offing.
The Treasury Department has traditionally offered very limited estimates of that possible “X-date” leaving others to weigh in.
But the paper was quick to add that “it is entirely possible that the debt ceiling will be reached prior to June 16, and the Congress will need to act earlier than many are expecting.”
The Bipartisan Policy Center (BPC) has also done extensive work to project possible X-date ranges. And while BPC hasn’t yet released a formal analysis for 2025, the group’s managing director of Economic Policy, Rachel Snyderman, reminded us in an episode of Yahoo Finance’s Capitol Gains podcast that workarounds only delay default for an unknown amount of time.
Extraordinary measures “could potentially carry them further into 2025 [but] that length of time, however, is not yet known for several reasons,” Snyderman explained, citing next year’s tax season and the unpredictability of government spending.
In any case, House Speaker Mike Johnson may have made next year’s standoff even more politically complex when he said that next year’s deal would include a debt limit raise of $1.5 trillion through the reconciliation process only if it’s paired with $2.5 trillion in cuts to “net mandatory spending.”
With this fiscal guessing game underway — and X-date projections likely to be flying around and making traders nervous — Republican lawmakers and the new Trump administration will be looking for a solution.
To be clear: This is not a situation Trump wanted. Last week he called the debt ceiling “a nasty TRAP set in place by the Radical Left Democrats,” adding that “they are looking to embarrass us” when it comes up for a vote.
In 2025, the debt ceiling’s fate is almost entirely in the hands of Republicans who will control the White House, Senate, and House of Representatives.
That’s especially true because Speaker Johnson is now promising to pass an increase using the reconciliation process that has become hyper-partisan in recent years as it allows the Senate to pass bills with 51 votes and exclude the minority party altogether.
Speaker Mike Johnson arrives at a GOP meeting Dec. 20 during the fight over the government shutdown and debt ceiling. (Allison Robbert for The Washington Post via Getty Images) ·The Washington Post via Getty Images
As Rep. Eric Burlison, a self-described fiscal conservative from Missouri, put it in a recent video: “Until this town gets serious about cutting spending, I’m not going to participate in the shell game of continuing to raise the debt limit.”
At least two dozen House Republicans take the same approach. That’s more than enough to tank a reconciliation deal, given the GOP’s slim margins.
Johnson’s plan to pair a debt limit with cuts to so-called “mandatory spending” could present yet another political landmine if an already controversial debt ceiling increase is paired with changes to programs like Medicaid, Medicare, or Social Security.
Ben Werschkul is Washington correspondent for Yahoo Finance.
Every Friday, Yahoo Finance’s Rachelle Akuffo, Rick Newman, and Ben Werschkul bring you a unique look at how U.S. policy and government affects your bottom line on Capitol Gains. Watch or listen to Capitol Gains on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you find your favorite podcasts.
